SSteeraMed
SteeraMed Bench · Combo Contribution Board

Combo Contribution Board

Existing knowledge modules compete head-to-head: how much recall drops when a module is removed from the pool (LOO contribution), plus each family's fair share (exact Shapley). Protocol identical to paper Table 1 (frozen, pre-computed snapshot).

Generated: 2026-08-20T17:31:44Z · Nomination snapshot: v2026.W34r2

Mechanism meets intervention head-on: hallmarks / TCM theories that survive on the board are those not yet targeted by the current intervention space — the R&D frontier.

Minimal mix: Hallmarks + NUT (152 modules)
152 modules
Recall@200.534
#ModuleFamilyLOO contribution
1skeletal muscle (A2)Hallmarks+0.020
2alpha-Linolenic acidNUT+0.020
3SpermineNUT+0.020
4skin (A2)Hallmarks+0.011
5CalciumNUT+0.011
6inflammation (A1)Hallmarks+0.010
7proteostasis (A1)Hallmarks+0.010
8stem cell (A1)Hallmarks+0.010
9breast (A2)Hallmarks+0.010
10endocrine (A2)Hallmarks+0.010
11immune inflammation (A2)Hallmarks+0.010
12liver (A2)Hallmarks+0.010
13ovary (A2)Hallmarks+0.010
14stomach (A2)Hallmarks+0.010
15bone metabolism (A3)Hallmarks+0.010
16carbohydrate (A3)Hallmarks+0.010
17purine (A3)Hallmarks+0.010
18b cell activation (A4)Hallmarks+0.010
19macrophage activation (A4)Hallmarks+0.010
20t cell activation (A4)Hallmarks+0.010
21cognition (A5)Hallmarks+0.010
22sleep regulation (A5)Hallmarks+0.010
23AspartameNUT+0.010
24Fish oilNUT+0.010
25Glutamic acidNUT+0.010
26GlutathioneNUT+0.010
27HyperforinNUT+0.010
28ManganeseNUT+0.010
29OrnithineNUT+0.010
30ProlineNUT+0.010
31TretinoinNUT+0.010
32CholecalciferolNUT+0.001
33extracellular matrix (A1)Hallmarks0.000
34intercellular (A1)Hallmarks0.000
35microbiota (A1)Hallmarks0.000
36mitochondrial (A1)Hallmarks0.000
37senescence (A1)Hallmarks0.000
38socio psychological (A1)Hallmarks0.000
39telomere (A1)Hallmarks0.000
40adipose (A2)Hallmarks0.000
41adrenal (A2)Hallmarks0.000
42bladder (A2)Hallmarks0.000
43blood vessel (A2)Hallmarks0.000
44bone (A2)Hallmarks0.000
45bone marrow (A2)Hallmarks0.000
46brain (A2)Hallmarks0.000
47digestion (A2)Hallmarks0.000
48endothelium (A2)Hallmarks0.000
49energy metabolism (A2)Hallmarks0.000
50intestine (A2)Hallmarks0.000
51joint (A2)Hallmarks0.000
52pancreas (A2)Hallmarks0.000
53prostate (A2)Hallmarks0.000
54tendon (A2)Hallmarks0.000
55testis (A2)Hallmarks0.000
56thymus (A2)Hallmarks0.000
57alcohol (A3)Hallmarks0.000
58free radical (A3)Hallmarks0.000
59glycoprotein (A3)Hallmarks0.000
60phospholipid (A3)Hallmarks0.000
61leukocyte migration (A4)Hallmarks0.000
62emotion (A5)Hallmarks0.000
63hematopoiesis (A5)Hallmarks0.000
64sensory (A5)Hallmarks0.000
65AdenineNUT0.000
66AlanineNUT0.000
67alpha-Tocopherol succinateNUT0.000
68ArginineNUT0.000
69Ascorbic acidNUT0.000
70AsparagineNUT0.000
71Aspartic acidNUT0.000
72ATPNUT0.000
73BetaineNUT0.000
74Chondroitin sulfateNUT0.000
75Citric acidNUT0.000
76Clove oilNUT0.000
77CreatineNUT0.000
78Folic acidNUT0.000
79GinsengNUT0.000
80GlycineNUT0.000
81HistidineNUT0.000
82IsoleucineNUT0.000
83L-GlutamineNUT0.000
84LeucineNUT0.000
85LysineNUT0.000
86MethionineNUT0.000
87N-AcetylglucosamineNUT0.000
88Omega-3 fatty acidsNUT0.000
89Omega-6 fatty acidsNUT0.000
90PhenylalanineNUT0.000
91Phosphatidyl serineNUT0.000
92PhosphocreatineNUT0.000
93PrasteroneNUT0.000
94Pyridoxal phosphateNUT0.000
95SerotoninNUT0.000
96Succinic acidNUT0.000
97TaurineNUT0.000
98TyrosineNUT0.000
99UbidecarenoneNUT0.000
100Vitamin ENUT0.000
101epigenetic (A1)Hallmarks-0.001
102gallbladder (A2)Hallmarks-0.001
103heart (A2)Hallmarks-0.001
104lymph (A2)Hallmarks-0.001
105structure (A2)Hallmarks-0.001
106lipid metabolism (A3)Hallmarks-0.001
107protein synthesis (A3)Hallmarks-0.001
108Adenosine phosphateNUT-0.001
109Evening primrose oilNUT-0.001
110PyridoxineNUT-0.001
111SerineNUT-0.001
112St. John's WortNUT-0.001
113nutrient sensing (A1)Hallmarks-0.010
114lung (A2)Hallmarks-0.010
115uterus (A2)Hallmarks-0.010
116uric acid (A3)Hallmarks-0.010
117adaptive immunity (A4)Hallmarks-0.010
118innate immunity (A4)Hallmarks-0.010
119AdemetionineNUT-0.010
120CalcitriolNUT-0.010
121CitrullineNUT-0.010
122CyanocobalaminNUT-0.010
123CysteineNUT-0.010
124Ephedra sinica rootNUT-0.010
125Ginkgo bilobaNUT-0.010
126IcosapentNUT-0.010
127MelatoninNUT-0.010
128MenadioneNUT-0.010
129Tetrahydrofolic acidNUT-0.010
130Vitamin ANUT-0.010
131autophagy (A1)Hallmarks-0.011
132circulation (A2)Hallmarks-0.011
133detoxification (A2)Hallmarks-0.011
134pleura (A2)Hallmarks-0.011
135BiotinNUT-0.011
136CholineNUT-0.011
137Choline salicylateNUT-0.011
138Coenzyme ANUT-0.011
139D-alpha-Tocopherol acetateNUT-0.011
140ErgocalciferolNUT-0.011
141Lipoic acidNUT-0.011
142NADHNUT-0.011
143NiacinNUT-0.011
144Pyruvic acidNUT-0.011
145RiboflavinNUT-0.011
146ThiamineNUT-0.011
147Vitamin DNUT-0.011
148thyroid (A2)Hallmarks-0.020
149TryptophanNUT-0.020
150genomic stability (A1)Hallmarks-0.021
151kidney (A2)Hallmarks-0.021
152motor function (A5)Hallmarks-0.021

Definition: LOO(M) = recall(pool) − recall(pool minus M). Positive = removing M drops recall = M carries irreplaceable signal in this pool; negative = removal improves recall. Overall tab sorts by the 5-disease mean; disease tabs sort by that disease.

Differences between combos are not corrected for multiple comparisons: in the paper's E8_2, none of the 50 combos survived BH correction; rankings are exploratory, not significance claims.

Structural gene coupling between the NUT family and DrugBank labels (nutrient targets come from DrugBank): NUT-related contributions on the intervention/mixed boards are systematically inflated — read with this caveat. In addition, disease labels themselves come from DrugBank approved indications (single source), and drugs not listed are implicitly treated as negatives — unapproved does not mean ineffective.

LOO measures marginal value relative to the reference pool: the same module changes value across pools (autophagy +0.0495 in the A1 pool vs −0.0105 in M1). Exact family-level Shapley removes this reference dependence; module-level Shapley is infeasible (332 modules cannot be enumerated). Negative LOO means removing the module IMPROVES recall (redundancy/interference in high-dimensional strongly-regularized pools), not measurement error.

Resolution floor: one recall hit = 0.05 per disease (0.053 for Athero, n_pos=19) / 0.010-0.011 on the 5-disease mean. LOO differences are hit-quantized with a minimum nonzero step of 0.010 — single-hit-scale differences may be pure protocol noise: borderline CV-LR ranks are sensitive to floating-point summation order, and a single hit can flip across execution environments (Shapley shares wobble by about ±0.003); family-share ORDER in the intervention pool (I3) was verified reproducible across two execution environments; mixed pools (M2/M3) were not independently recomputed, but their minimum adjacent share gap (0.008) exceeds twice the noise magnitude (2×0.003), so order flips are unlikely (gap-based inference).